I’m a member of a film critics circle for women and recently, one member of the group wrote a review for a HUGELY popular movie site that sent the group in an empowering frenzy! She started off the review with the following quote:
“Noble, brilliant suit-wearing Negros fight for equality in racist Texas circa 1935. All the white people are toothless, evil pig farmers. Denzel insults his white audience with caricatures.”
She then went on to say “I wasn’t going to review “The Great Debaters” knowing full well the ugly emails I would get if I don’t like a movie made by or about black people, I’m a racist…(blah, blah, blah)…here’s her DISCLAIMER, which follwed the foot in her mouth:
“I leave for my 7th trip to Africa next week. And, just so you know, I don’t do Africa behind a big white air-conditioned bus. I camp out with the people. I know more about African culture from first-hand, feet on the ground experience then all of my black neighbors and friends put together.” She went on to say:
“If you forgotten the cruel fight for equality, director and star Denzel Washington wants to shove it right back in your face. Denzel’s huge fan base might have either not known or forgotten America’s ugly past, so here it is. There is even a lynching.”
She summed this up by saying Denzel needs therapy!
WHEW! And that’s just the beginning.
Those who know me well, know that I don’t bite my tongue, having been fired once for telling a boss that ‘talking to you is like banging on a door and getting no sound.’ She let me go later that day…LOL!
So, on that note, I had to respond to this “blatant bash” disguised as a movie review. Here’s what I said:
“Everyone is entitled to their opinion. I’d just like to say as a grand-daughter of an African American Legacy, it is not so far fetched that this film is true to character.
My family has a 120-yr old collection debuting at the Smithsonian Anacostia Museum in DC in 2009. Amongst the collection are the letters of my cousin who was training to be a Tuskegee Airman in 1943, before that, in the early 1900’s my grand uncle was the founder of Boston’s first Victorian Orchestra, we had an aunt who was a song and dance actress in Russia during the 20’s. Although there were lynchings and racism (especially in Tuskegee) it did not stop the progress of education, not in my family or in other prominent blacks at the time.
I’m happy to say that I watched Nightline with Oprah and Denzel, which the only surviving Debater spoke…racism did exist BUT they did not walk around wearing “pity or a slave mentality” on their shoulder. And white people during that time were as they were depicted in that film, even worst, some weren’t…
It is time that America face the truth that all black ppl during that time of racist/opression (which still exists today) were not uneducated “Negroes.”
The Great Debaters is a wonderful film which brings to light the “Willie Lynch Theory” which is still used today. I think as a member of this group it is important to have this kind of open dialogue so that we can break the myth of what America’s past has lied about and to embrace the truths that make us uncomfortable.
As a journalist and filmmaker, it’s time that we see black people as we really were and not how America wants us to be seen…
Having to “DEBATE” The GREAT DEBATERS is a start of great therapy for us all…”
The next email we received was her RESIGNATION and the group continued to “check” her on her ignorance with a happy farewell and good riddance.
OUR DISCLAIMER: We are the most diverse group in the nation and so this was NOT an excerpt of Diary of a Mad Black Woman…these are all hues of black, white, latino and beautiful women young and mature.
I SALUTE Denzel Washington, Oprah and the BIG WIG Weinsteins for showing a film that depicts our culture in a light we’ve always known and have been proud of as African Americans in this country. A film starring newcomer, Denzel Whitaker (who’s not Forest Whitaker’s son); Jurnee Smollett (most known for her role in Eve’s Bayou as the young spitfire) and Oscar winner Forest Whitaker.
I encourage everyone to see this movie for entertainment and educational purposes; then I’d like to know your thoughts. I believe this is the best film Denzel has ever made. The directorial vision is magnificent and the moment Denzel steps on screen, you know that walk which he’s made his signature, that bounce of determination. Yet, there’s something different about his swagger this time: It’s the walk of a director/actor who knows he’s got this film in the bag.
Denzel’s portrayal of (Professor Tolson) believed every word he delivered in this film–and every actor beside him had to step up in each scene, bringing their performances to a heightened level of sophistication and a tear jerking experience.
One of the moments which sticks out to me is the preparation for the debating team, a chant which they recited to build their confidence during a time when the world was against them. Feel free to hang it where you can see it.
Professor Tolson: Who’s the Judge?
Debating Team: God!
Professor Tolson: Why?
Debating Team: Because he decides who wins or who loses, not your opponent.
Professor Tolson: Who’s your opponent?
Debating Team: He doesn’t exist.
Professor Tolson: Why?
Debating Team: Because he’s a mere dissenting voice to the truth that I speak.
I may not have gotten this word for word, but I want to end with this: There is always opposition in life and this film critic, in my opinion is a “mere dissenting voice to the truth this movie evokes.” A film inspired by a beautiful article published in American Legacy Magazine. A publication which celebrates the life and times of the African Diaspora.
The Great Debaters is a film inspired by a true story. About a team of Wiley College students who were coached by a professor who is considered a “rebel” who went against the grain of Jim Crown south and challenged intellectuals, share croppers and a team of students to debate when their voices were silenced. The debating team went on to debate the power team at Harvard University…and won.
This is a remarkable film about the courage and ability to stand against the odds. This is a film to let all the critics know that we have always risen, even in 1935 when the Jim Crow era was a man made contingency to keep us on our knees.
Denzel is an amazing director and extraordinary actor–this time, I’d like to see him win an Oscar for playing a man that will make all of us proud, rather than a crooked cop, which some of us would much rather see in American cinema…just ask the critic.
The Great Debaters opens Christmas Day…gift yourself!
.jpg)
Denzel as Professor Tolson (Photo by David Lee)

Denzel with Jurnee Smollett (Samantha), Nate Parker (Henry Lowe) and Denzel Whitaker (James Farmer, Jr.): Photo by David Lee

From Left to Right: Denzel Whitaker (James Farmer, Jr.), Jermaine W. Willias (Burgess), unknown extras as Wiley College students, Nate Parker (Henry Lowe), Jurnee Smollett (Samantha), unknown extras as Wiley College students.
Wiley College beats Paul Quinn–their first victory as a debate team.
Photo by David Lee.
If you’d like to see the full critic review, click here:
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/click/author-3571/reviews.php?rid=1696557&cats=1&switches=rotten&sortby=add_date&page=